Mayor Tate’s Excellent Adventure
Tom Tate held a press conference this week and chose to question with a question. Liam Walsh, who has been following this story since February, asked how long the mayor's dinner with Donald Trump had lasted at Mar-a-Lago.
That was private, Tate said.
Who was at the table. Also private.
Had he always intended to pay for the hospitality himself. Yes.
How much had he paid. He wasn't going to say.
Tate stopped there and asked a question of his own.
“Are you from the ABC?”
Yes.
“Fuck off.”
Mayor Tate left. He apologised the following day for the language. He did not change his answers.
It is worth remembering why the questions in the first place. In February, Tate flew to Florida as part of an overseas trip that also took in Milan and Dubai. Ratepayers covered almost $33,000 in flights. Gold Coast City Council's records of the journey are, on the whole, meticulous. Apparently, Milan came with shoe advice, a departure time and an identification requirement. Dubai came with briefing notes. Three days at Mar-a-Lago produced one line: “Meeting with Trump Organization.”
Between Florida and Los Angeles, Tate spent a week in Barbados. That part was private and he paid for it himself. He also personally paid for a first-class upgrade during the wider journey. Nobody had to explain the distinction. A personal holiday tucked inside a ratepayer-funded trip was personal, so Tate paid for it. It is the sort of instinct that makes the Mar-a-Lago arrangement harder to explain, not easier.
While he was there, Queensland developer David Young was preparing to sign a $1.5 billion agreement with Eric Trump for a 91-storey Trump-branded tower in Surfers Paradise. No formal development application was yet before council. Tate later told the ABC he'd been invited as mayor, not as himself. “I'm pretty sure Tom Tate wouldn't have gotten an invite; mayor of the Gold Coast got an invite.” He described the hospitality as “a gift to the city, not to me.”
His register of interests recorded two gifts from the Trump Organization covering meals, accommodation and transfers from Miami airport. He has since amended it, saying the accommodation and transfers were always meant to be paid for personally, and that he settled the account once the invoice arrived. The meals, and a red cap, remain on the register as gifts. He has not released that invoice. The ABC requested it under right to information. Tate has declined to provide it, and has said only that he did not get “mates rates”.
There is no written record of the Mar-a-Lago invitation either. His office says it was verbal. Among the many photographs published from the trip, there are none from the three days in Florida. None of which proves anything happened that shouldn't have. It only means that a mayor capable of documenting an olympic torch walk down to the minute developed, for one leg of the journey, an unusual case of privacy.
There was another complication. The tower fell over first.
Announced in February, it was gone by May, less than three months later. By then opposition to the proposal had produced a petition with more than 140,000 signatures. Young blamed the increasing toxicity of the Trump brand. The Trump Organization blamed Altus for failing to meet its financial obligations. Tate had his own view. “It's all about money” he explained.
Which leaves the dinner. Tate has described it more than once and has consistently maintained that he dined with Trump: tomahawk steaks, expensive wine, Eric and Lara Trump present, the president greeting him as “Mr Mayor”.
The White House told the ABC that the president and first lady did not dine with Tate's group. The Trump Organization went further. It called Tate's account a “complete fabrication” and said Trump stopped briefly at the table before going to a separate dinner. A business associate of Tate's who says he was there backs the mayor's version.
The Honking Goose was not at Mar-a-Lago and cannot settle the matter of the steaks. It notes only that the Mayor of the Gold Coast says he dined with the President of the United States, the president's own organisation says he did not, and when a reporter tried to pin down what happened, the reply was not an answer.
Tate says his recollection is correct. He says the invoice is paid. He has not said how much, or produced it. The following day he apologised for the way he spoke to Walsh. The rest remained unchanged.
Perhaps it is all perfectly straightforward.
An invoice would be a useful place to start.