The Trouble With Remembering Exactly
Four copies of Swan Song: Diana, My Sister went missing from a lorry in the Netherlands last month, taken overnight from a parked trailer while the driver slept. It is a small, almost decorative detail in a story that otherwise concerns itself with the King, the Palace and a man who has spent thirty years deciding how his sister should be remembered. There is something fitting about a book on this particular subject being taken before anyone had permission to read it. Diana rarely got much say in who got to her story first either.
Charles Spencer's memoir arrived last month carrying two allegations that have swallowed most of the coverage around it. He says that in the days after Diana's death, his former brother-in-law told him during an argument over the funeral, "Rest assured, we'll forget her soon enough." He also remembers a separate call in which Charles sounded, in Spencer's phrase, "giddily elated, like a lottery winner," and writes that he suspects the Prince's first thought must have been relief at his sudden freedom to marry Camilla.
Buckingham Palace, an institution that usually prefers silence to combat, made an exception. It said grief can "cloud reason, affect judgment and colour memory in ways others do not recognise, even many years after such a loss." Spencer called this "classic gaslighting" and told the Mail on Sunday it is not every day one wakes up gaslit by the King. Nobody involved disputes that the conversations happened. The entire argument concerns what was actually said in them, and whether three decades of grief and a brother's considerable fondness for being right have edited the transcript that exists only in Charles Spencer's memory.
This ought to be his specialist subject. He read History at Oxford, sits as a Fellow of the Royal Historical Society, and has written nine books before this one, mostly about people considerably harder to interrogate than his own recollections. A historian's professional value lies in treating witnesses with polite suspicion and resisting the version of events that simply feels true. Spencer has built a career doing precisely this to other people's dead relatives. He told the BBC it was his "duty" to write this one "as an eyewitness to history," which is a fine sentence for a man to say about himself the week before being cross-examined on it.
Pressed by Laura Kuenssberg on whether he could really know what Charles had been thinking on the phone that day, he grew noticeably less certain than the book allows. "I cannot be sure," he said. "I'm saying that's what I assume from the tone is a possibility." The manuscript's confident "must have been" had, somewhere between the page and the studio, quietly downgraded itself to a guess.
There is a second complication, and it belongs to Piers Morgan rather than Charles. The book placed Morgan at the Daily Mirror when it published intrusive gym photographs of Diana in 1993. He was in fact still at The Sun, and did not become Mirror editor until October 1995. Spencer has apologised, called it an incorrect assumption, and confirmed the second edition will be corrected, all while maintaining that his account of their separate phone call about the funeral is "accurate." Morgan says he intends to keep pursuing legal action regardless. It doesn't prove anything about the Charles allegations. It simply demonstrates, with unfortunate timing, what happens to a man's certainty the moment it meets a fact somebody else can check.
There is a third detail worth noting, and it involves the newspaper carrying all of this. Swan Song is being serialised in the Daily Mail. Spencer's previous memoir was serialised in its sister title, the Mail on Sunday. In 2017 the same publisher, Associated Newspapers, was made to apologise to Spencer in open court and pay him damages for falsely claiming he had refused Diana shelter at Althorp after her marriage collapsed. He has, more than once now, taken his most personal and most contested material to the one publisher a court has already found guilty of getting his relationship with Diana wrong. Make of that what you will. He plainly has.
Usually the historian gets to worry about his sources. Here Spencer is one of them, a fact the book does not dwell on. There have been many people qualified to explain Diana over the years. The Palace had a version. Charles had one, and so did she. The papers ran a version that pursued her while she was alive and discovered its reverence with striking speed the week she wasn't. Harry has published his account of a father sitting quietly on the end of his bed. Now her brother has added his, and he does not sound like a man waiting for corroboration.
The stolen copies will presumably turn up. So, conceivably, might some note or diary that settles the telephone calls for good. For now there is only Spencer's memory, offered as history, defended as truth, and quietly downgraded to a possibility the moment he was asked to prove it.
Diana spent much of her adult life surrounded by people explaining what she thought, what she wanted and what had happened to her. Thirty years after her death, remarkably little has changed.